Should I Repair or Replace My Residential Garage Door?

Should I Repair or Replace My Residential Garage Door?

Your garage door is more than just an entryway for your car. It’s an important part of your home’s security and curb appeal. When it starts acting up, you might wonder whether you should repair it or replace it altogether.

This decision can be tricky, but don’t worry! We’ll break down the factors to consider, so you can make the best choice for your situation.

Assessing the Damage

Before deciding on garage door repairs or a complete garage door replacement, it’s crucial to assess the damage. Some problems are minor and can be fixed easily, while others might indicate a more serious issue.

Common Repairable Issues

  1. Broken Springs: If your door isn’t opening smoothly, it might have broken springs. These can be replaced without needing a new door.
  2. Worn-out Rollers: Noisy garage doors often have worn-out rollers. Replacing these can make your door run quietly again.
  3. Misaligned Tracks: Sometimes, the door might go off track. A professional can realign the tracks quickly and easily.
  4. Damaged Panels: A dent or scratch on a panel doesn’t mean you need a whole new door. Often, you can replace just the damaged section.

When to Consider Replacement

While many issues can be fixed with garage door repairs, sometimes a replacement is the better option.

  1. Age of the Door: If your garage door is more than 15-20 years old, it might be time to consider a replacement. Older doors can lack the safety features and insulation of newer models.
  2. Frequent Breakdowns: Are you constantly calling for repairs? It might be more cost-effective to invest in a new door that won’t give you trouble.
  3. Severe Damage: If your door has major structural damage, like a broken frame or severe warping, a replacement is often the best choice.
  4. Energy Efficiency: Newer garage doors come with better insulation. If you notice your garage is too cold in winter or too hot in summer, a new door might help with energy efficiency.

Cost Considerations

Budget is always a big factor in any home improvement decision. Let’s look at the cost implications of repairs vs. replacement.

Repair Costs

Garage door repairs can vary in cost. Simple fixes like replacing springs or rollers might be relatively inexpensive. However, costs can add up if you’re constantly fixing different parts. It’s essential to weigh the cumulative cost of repairs against the price of a new door.

Replacement Costs

Replacing a garage door is a bigger upfront expense. However, it can save you money in the long run by reducing repair and maintenance costs. Additionally, a new door can increase your home’s value and improve energy efficiency, which can save on utility bills.


Deciding whether to repair or replace your residential garage door can be challenging. It’s essential to assess the damage, consider the age and condition of your door, and think about the long-term costs and benefits.

While garage door repairs are suitable for minor issues, a garage door replacement might be the best option for older, frequently breaking doors or those with significant damage.